National Regulation of Public Procurement
Key features of public procurement system
- Priority for procurement of services and works
- Single procurement organization (UGAP) with a long history of operation.
- Special attention is paid to the life cycle costs of procured goods, work and services
EU Law
- Directive 2014/23/EU on the award of concession contracts dated February 26, 2014;
- Directive 2014/24/EU on public procurement dated February 26, 2014;
- Directive 2014/25/EU on procurement by entities operating in the water, energy, transport and postal services sectors dated February 26, 2014;
- Directive 2014/55/EU on electronic invoicing in public procurement dated April 16, 2014;
- Directive 2009/81/EC on procurement in the defense and security sector dated July 13, 2009;
- Regulation EU 2016/7 dated January 5, 2016 establishing the standard form for the European Single Procurement Document (ESPD)
International Agreements
- WTO Agreement on Government Procurement (GPA)
National Law
- The Public Procurement Code (LeCode de la commande publique) is a codified legislative act regulating public procurement relations (taking into account the differences between public contracts, concession agreements and public-private partnerships). Effective since April 1, 2019, it consolidated the provisions of more than 30 regulations. It consists of two parts: the first is legislative (la partie législative) and the second is regulatory (la partie réglementaire). With a structure that follows the chronology of the contract, it contains information on the rules of supplier selection, contract awarding/ amendment/ termination and requirements for the performance of contract obligations. The initial version included 1,747 articles, with the latest changes effective 1 January 2023.
- Regional Code (Le Code général des collectivités territoriales) (concerning the interaction between tender commissions and regional authorities).
- Code of Administrative Justice (Le code de la justice administrative) (regarding judicial procedures on appeals against the outcome of competitive tendering procedures).
- Criminal Code (Le code pénal) (for offences relating to the violation of the principles of free and equal access to public procurement – favoritism). The Sapin II Law dated December 9, 2016 “On Transparency, Combating Corruption and Modernization of Economic Life” sets the penalty for favoritism at two years' imprisonment and a fine of EUR 200,000. Examples of favoritism include disclosure of insider information, artificial splitting of contracts (le saucissonnage) in order to avoid a formal tender procedure. Illegal profit making (la prise illégale d'intérêt), corruption (la corruption), influence peddling (le trafic d'influence), bribery (la concussion) are the most common offences in public procurement.
- Notices and orders that are annexes to the Public Procurement Code (21 annexes in the current version of the document).
- Compendium of General Administrative Rules (Les cahiers des clauses administratives générales, CCAG) contains provisions applicable to a certain category of contracts. They are non-binding. They apply only to government contracts that specifically mention them. The Legal Department of the Ministry of Economics, Finance, Industry and Digital Sovereignty has developed a Practical Guide on the application of the relevant administrative rules.
- The Compendium of General Technical Regulations (Les cahiers des clauses techniques générales) establishes technical regulations for construction and civil engineering.
- Normative instruments aimed at making public procurement “green”:
- Law No. 2021-1104 dated August 22, 2021 “On Combating Climate Change and Building Resilience” (Loi № 2021-1104 du 22 août 2021) — Art. 35–39;
- Decree No. 2022-767 dated May 2, 2022 (Décret n° 2022-767 du 2 mai 2022).
- Normative instruments that incentivize the development of a circular economy:
- Law No. 2020-105 dated February 10, 2020 “On Combating Waste and the Circular Economy" (Loi № 2020-105 du 10 février 2020) — Art. 58.
- Decree No. 2021-254 dated March 9, 2021 (Décret n° 2021-254 du 9 mars 2021) establishes the obligation to purchase, through public procurement, goods produced by reuse or recycling.
- The Order dated December 3, 2021 (Arrêté du 3 décembre 2021) establishes rules for the declaration of expenses related to the acquisition of goods made from recycled materials.
- Public procurement contracts and concession contracts entered into before April 1, 2019 are subject to the provisions of normative instruments in force before that date. A list of normative instruments is available at the link
SAI France Cases
Use of Consulting Services by Government Agencies
At the end of 2021, public procurement of consultancy services from private organizations amounted to EUR 890 million. More than 75% falls on the services related to development of software solutions, and 25% represent scientific research, development and expert support of implementation of state projects.
In 2015, at the request of the Finance Committee of the French Senate, SAI France conducted a value for money audit of public spending on consulting services. Among the key findings of the report is the lack of a well-regulated process for procuring consulting services.
On January 19, 2022, the French Prime Minister published a policy paper with proposals to improve the public procurement process for consulting services, including a 15% budget cut.
Audit Objectives:
1. To analyze the implementation of the 2015 audit recommendations.
2. To assess the development of the public procurement system in terms of consulting services procurement in accordance with the tasks outlined by the Prime Minister in 2022.
- Lack of accurate data on the level and pattern of expenditure on consultancy services, mainly due to the lack of efficient accounting and monitoring tools.
- SAI notes that there are cases where services are procured to do tasks that are the direct responsibility of public authorities. The SAI calls for clear rules for projects that are outsourced.
- The analysis of the main stages of awarding and performance of more than 100 government contracts for consulting services awarded from 2019 to 2022 revealed the following problems: non-compliance with formal procedures established by the Public Procurement Code, exceeding financial limits or contract deadlines.
1. To establish a common definition of “consulting services provided by private entities”.
2. To implement consultancy-related data monitoring and management systems in all government agencies. To develop clear rules for budget allocation for consulting services and update accounting tools and standards for accounting of relevant expenditures.
3. To develop practical guidance for public institutions to approach external private entities for consulting services.
4. To ensure unified management of the procurement process of consulting services at the interdepartmental level by clarifying and formalizing the responsibilities of the Public Procurement Department.
5. To include all external consultancy costs incurred under framework agreements in the budgets of the relevant ministries.
6. To optimize external consulting costs. To the extent possible, to accomplish tasks using internal resources, without outsourcing.
7. To implement a system of internal control of consulting expenses, risk assessment and quality of contract performance.
Adapted Companies
According to Art. L.5213-13-1 of the Labor Code, adapted companies are companies that contribute to the development of territories and the creation of an inclusive economic environment favorable to people with disabilities. The Ministry of Labor provides additional subsidies to support these types of businesses
Audit Objectives:
1 To evaluate the effectiveness of the state program for the development of disability-friendly enterprises.
2. To analyze the mechanism of public procurement as a tool for the development of disability-friendly enterprises.
- Public procurement represents a small but important source of financing for adapted companies. DAE estimates that the volume of relevant public procurement in 2022 amounted to 285 contracts worth EUR 7.43 million (total value of public contracts in 2020 amounted to EUR 15 billion).
- Social criterion is one of the priority criteria in the selection process of competitive bids. A target quantitative indicator has been developed to promote socially responsible public procurement (25% of the total volume), but there is no special indicator for enterprises working with people with disabilities. As DAE experts note, despite efforts to develop social public procurement, growth remains limited (up from 4.4% in 2016 to 6.1% in 2020). In comparison, the green procurement market grew from 18% to 30% in the same period.
- The SAI estimates that the public procurement tool is not able to significantly improve the financial performance of disability-friendly enterprises without reducing the costs of other social employment support programs.
Recommendations concerning public procurement:
to amend Article L.2113-14 of the Public Procurement Code to avoid competition between adapted companies and other state programs supporting social employment